About Buylists

Ready to Submit a Buylist?

Log in to your account, then click here.

 

What is a buylist?

A buylist is a request from a customer for us to buy their cards. If you have 3 or fewer cards to sell, we are happy to buy them from you at the shop counter. If your list is rather long, we appreciate you submitting that on this website to help optimize the process. 

You must be logged in to your customer account to submit a buylist. When creating a new account, you may be asked to confirm and verify your email address so be sure you have access to your email account.

Pricing and desired quantities for cards are listed with a Cash Price and a Credit Price. You can toggle between them before you submit your Buylist. After you submit it, bring the cards to us! It may take us up to 1 business day to review (often much quicker), after which you will have the option to go ahead and approve it or remove some or all of the cards from the list. If we don't hear back from you within 15 days the buylist will be completed with the changes we made, and credit will be applied to your account. If you requested cash, you must come in to collect it. Cash buylists for over $50 will be written a check.

Buylists can be brought in between 2pm and 8pm Mon-Sat, 2-5 sundays

Buylists over $100 cash or $200 store credit must be approved by a manager

We will do our best to complete your transaction while you are in the store, but larger buylists may need to be left with us for up to one business day.

Please note: We do not buy oversized cards or art cards. Prices can fluctuate dramatically in a short period of time, especially for new card sets and promos. We reserve the right to change our buylist price at any time, and you have the option to refuse our offer.

Store Credit

Store credit can be applied to your account when you sell us your cards. That credit is then available for you to use to buy more cards on this website, or you can use it to purchase other items in our store. Just ask!